View previous stories|
Nearly two-thirds of children lack access to welfare safety net, risking ‘vicious cycle of poverty’
by Isabel Ortiz
Director of the Social Protection Department at ILO
Social protection is critical in helping children escape poverty and its devastating effects, yet, the vast majority of children have no effective social protection coverage, UNICEF and the ILO said in a new joint report.
Evidence shows clearly that cash transfers play a vital role in breaking the vicious cycle of poverty and vulnerability. Yet, globally only 35 per cent of children on average are covered by social protection which reaches 87 per cent in Europe and Central Asia, 66 per cent in the Americas, 28 per cent in Asia and 16 per cent in Africa.
At the same time, one in five children lives in extreme poverty (less than US$ 1.90 a day), and almost half of the world’s children live in ‘moderate’ poverty (under $3.10 a day). Almost everywhere, poverty disproportionately affects children, as they are twice as likely as adults to live in extreme poverty.
The report calls for the rapid expansion of child and family benefits, with the aim of achieving universal social protection for children, as well as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Such benefits are a key element of policies to improve access to nutrition, health and education, as well as reducing child labour and child poverty and vulnerability.
The report notes that universal social protection for children is not a privilege of wealthy countries. A number of developing countries have made or achieved (or nearly achieved) universal coverage, such as Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Mongolia and South Africa.
But in many other countries, social protection programmes for children struggle with limited coverage, inadequate benefit levels, fragmentation and weak institutionalization. Some governments undergoing fiscal consolidation are even cutting allowances, instead of extending benefits as countries had agreed in the SDGs.
“Child poverty can be reduced overnight with adequate social protection,” said Isabel Ortiz, Director of Social Protection, ILO. “To improve the lives of all children is an issue of priorities and political will: even the poorest countries have fiscal space to extend social protection floors.”
"Poverty hits children the hardest, since its consequences can last a lifetime. The poor nutrition and lost years of education that often result are tragic both for the individual and for his or her community and society,” said Alexandra Yuster, UNICEF Associate Director and Chief of Social Policy. “Countries need to put children first and reach every child with social protection to end poverty for good."
When Member States ratified the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, agreed in 2015 with its 17 Sustainable Development Goals, they agreed to the global initiative’s top priority, namely eradicating poverty.
State benefits play vital role in preventing poverty
State benefits from public funds, in the form of cash grants, “play a vital role in breaking the vicious cycle of poverty and vulnerability”, the report insists. Of 139 countries covered by the report, on average, they spend 1.1 per cent of their wealth on children up to 14 years old.
“There is a huge underinvestment gap that needs to be covered,” said Isabel Ortiz, Director of the Social Protection Department at ILO. “The numbers worsen by region. In Africa, for instance, children represent 40 per cent of the African population overall, but only 0.6 per cent is actually invested in social protection for children.”
Children are twice as likely as adults to live in extreme poverty, the report continues, with lack of access to education and poor nutrition among the most significant long-term impacts.
“While social protection cash transfers are vital for children, they shouldn’t stand alone,” said David Stewart, Chief of Child Poverty and Social Protection Unit at UNICEF. “They have to be combined with other services – if a child is living in a household with sufficient resources and if they don’t have access to educational health, it makes a big difference. So, it’s about combining these interventions together.”
A number of developing countries have made real progress in realising universal social protection programs. In Mongolia for example, which has achieved universal social protection for children, austerity measures threaten these gains however.
“Recently, due to fiscal pressures from international financial institutions, they have been advising the Government to target the universal benefit, Ms. Ortiz explained. “So it’s one of these cases where fiscal consolidation or austerity short-term…may be having long-term impacts on children. So the UN message is to try to look at the longer-term.”
Improving all children’s lives ‘is an issue of political will’
“Child poverty can be reduced overnight with adequate social protection,” Ms. Ortiz said, adding that improving the lives of all children “is an issue of priorities and political will – even the poorest countries have fiscal space to extend social protection”.
“Ultimately, the extension of social protection is always about Government’s will. It is because a Government realizes about the important developmental impacts of protecting people, particularly those that are vulnerable, across the lifecycle, so in times of childhood, in old age, in times of maternity, protections are particularly needed.”
Statement by UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Michelle Bachelet to the Conference: Together to achieve Universal Social Protection by 2030
It is an honour to speak at this conference, and to participate in this effort to ensure social protection for every human being.
The Global Partnership for Universal Social Protection to Achieve the Sustainable Development Goals is an exceptional initiative in support of one of the essential commitments of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. The partnership has shown that social protection is an essential tool for reducing poverty and a fundamental human right.
What is the goal of development? It is to improve the well-being of every member of society. People are not simply the how of development – they need to be the why of development. They are what development is for. True development generates greater social justice, reducing inequalities, which erase the fundamental rights of those who are poor or marginalised.
This is the core message of the 2030 Agenda. It is about including everyone – with “no-one left behind” and indeed, a priority on reaching those furthest behind. It is about rooting out and correcting the causes of poverty – the multiple human rights violations that deprive people of power, of control over resources, of a voice in their government, economy and society.
The 2030 Agenda is a roadmap for practical and detailed measures, which seek to improve our support for the universal human rights of every person, including every individual’s right to development. It is an opportunity to defeat poverty, lift discrimination, level out power imbalances and realise rights.
Our work today will mostly focus on Sustainable Development Goal 1.3, which aims to implement social protection systems and measures for all -- and, particularly, to achieve substantial social protection coverage for the poor and marginalised.
SDG 1.3 flows directly from Article 22 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, laying out the right to social security. That right includes access to adequate and affordable health-care and income security – for the elderly, unemployed, sick, injured; for people with disabilities, in need of maternity care, or in other situations of vulnerability, so that they can retain their fundamental dignity.
These are profound and foundational commitments. ILO has done a great job in researching and showing evidence that even the poorest countries can afford a universal social protection system, through the social protection floor approach.
For example, an ILO study from 2017 indicated that a social protection system including allowances for all children; maternity benefits for all women with newborns; benefits for all persons with severe disabilities; and universal old-age pensions costs on average just 1.6 per cent of GDP.
A range of developing countries have already established universal social protection, and many of our speakers today have experience of setting up measures for social protection in resource-challenged situations -- as I do. We can speak to the very powerful effect these systems can have in curbing poverty and marginalisation, reinvigorating the economy, and upholding human dignity.
There are also wide-ranging ripple effects, which extend across society. Human rights are the drivers of peace, security, confidence, resilience, and public trust.
Inclusive, participatory societies benefit from the skills of everyone; and when essential services are provided, such as adequate and accessible health care, education and housing, everyone reaps massive economic, political and social benefits.
Conversely, societies which exclude groups of people from essential opportunities and resources are holding back the ability of the entire nation to develop to its full potential. These violations of fundamental economic, social and cultural rights breed grievances and tensions that are deeply corrosive of social harmony and can give rise to conflict.
At least 821 million people go hungry every day, according to FAO. Youth unemployment is rising: 70 million young people were unemployed in 2017. Short-sighted austerity measures are eroding social protection systems, with short-term cost-saving measures, that ignore human rights obligations and commitments to realise the SDGs.
We need to encourage national leaders to ring-fence budgets to ensure that rights are promoted, and that essential services remain accessible even in the case of budget cuts.
To take one example, social protection measures are essential to combatting youth unemployment - generating access to further education, improving skills relevant to labour markets and securing rights to health, food, water and sanitation, education and housing.
Another example: social protection can enable people with disabilities to gain independence and greater participation in society, including their employability. But only 27 per cent of persons with severe disabilities worldwide receive a disability benefit.
Almost two-thirds of the world’s children – 1.3 billion – are not covered by social protection measures. 71 per cent of our fellow human beings are either not protected, or only partially protected, by social security systems.
Even in countries with universal pension coverage, the level of benefits is often insufficient to push older people out of poverty.
This is particularly true for older women who have invested years of their lives in caring for children and older parents. Social protection policies also need to promote equality between women and men, instead of deepening the imbalances between them.
The numbers are disturbing and signal that we must urgently step up our efforts to get back on track is we want to achieve the SDGs, particularly zero hunger, decent work and universal social protection.
I wholeheartedly join you in calling on governments, civil society organizations and social and development partners to join this Global Partnership, and to work towards truly universal social protection. We can afford to enable everyone to live in dignity and enjoy this fundamental human right.
* Access the ILO, UNICEF report on children & social protection: http://bit.ly/2RFzxGN
* International conference on Universal Child Grants video recordings: http://socialprotection.org/international-conference-universal-child-grants
http://www.ilo.org/global/topics/social-security/lang--en/index.htm http://www.unicef.org/press-releases/only-one-third-children-covered-social-protection-ilo-unicef http://socialprotection-humanrights.org/ http://www.socialprotectionfloorscoalition.org/
* ILO: World Social Protection Report 2017-19: Universal social protection to achieve the SDGs (450pp): http://bit.ly/2ywslpU
* Ensuring inclusion and combatting discrimination in social protection programmes: The role of human rights standards, by Magdalena Sepulveda Carmona: http://bit.ly/2Sb8ALh
* UNRISD: Overcoming Inequalities in a Fractured World: Between Elite Power and Social Mobilization: http://bit.ly/2R3aYUC http://bit.ly/2MRyliU http://bit.ly/1LeZJAq
Visit the related web page
2019 will be another year of crises
by Richard Skretteberg
Norwegian Refugee Council
At the start of 2018, 68.5 million people were displaced by war and violent conflict. There is little evidence to suggest that we will see this number decreasing in 2019.
A hope for 2019 is that old, relentless conflicts will be resolved. But political solutions require political will, like we witnessed this summer when longstanding enemies Ethiopia and Eritrea signed a peace agreement. This is good news for all countries in the Horn of Africa.
However, we are still facing numerous challenges: What will happen in Syria? Will the peace agreement in South Sudan hold? Can we get a peace agreement in Yemen? Will the Rohingya refugees be able to return to Myanmar?
Lack of money
One major problem is rich countries’ lack of will to stand up for the world’s vulnerable, displaced people. The great gap between humanitarian needs and funds made available by the international community continues to increase.
By the start of December 2018, only 57 per cent of the UN and its 2018 humanitarian partners’ emergency appeal was covered. According to the emergency appeal for 2019, 132 million people will need humanitarian aid in the coming year.
On 17 December, the UN General Assembly adopted a new global compact for refugees. The hope is that the countries will now act on the promises of better international responsibility sharing in practice. Rich countries that receive relatively few refugees must increase their support to countries that welcome high numbers of refugees. It is also important that more countries open up their doors to resettlement refugees. These are people who cannot be protected in their current location, and are resettled through the UN to other countries.
In the first ten months of 2018, only 45,874 refugees were resettled to a third country. The UN estimates that 1.4 million people will need protection through the resettlement programme in 2019.
Today, 85 per cent of the world’s refugees are living in low- and middle-income countries. As humanitarian crises last longer and needs increase, aid is not sufficient. The innocent victims of conflicts, the civilians, always pay the highest price. They will also do so in 2019 unless we step up our efforts. For that to happen, we need courageous politicians with a will to act.
An ocean of humanitarian crises
From a global perspective, developments in sub-Saharan Africa and the Middle East are causes for concern, which they also will be in 2019. However, the situation of the Rohingya who fled from Myanmar, violence driving people through Central America to the United States, and the situation in Venezuela have again forced people in Southeast Asia and Latin America to become refugees.
Africa - The neglected continent
The number of displaced people in Africa has been on the rise since 2011 – from 13.3 million in 2011 to 22.4 million in 2017. Many countries have also repeatedly appeared on NRC’s annual list of the world’s ten most neglected crises, where the majority of countries are African.
Millions of people fleeing some of the world’s poorest and most vulnerable states not only fuels enormous humanitarian crises, but also prevents development in regions such as the Great Lakes, the Horn of Africa and the Sahel.
The migration flow to Europe in 2015 drew attention to the situation in the Sahel region. The political focus on migration and terrorism promptly attracted money for anti-terrorist operations, as well as coast and border guards. But the vulnerable civilian population in the region’s conflict areas is yet to see stability. They are still suffering from violence and displacement.
In Mali, only 52 per cent of the funds needed to help people affected by conflict and violence has been received as we approach the end of 2018. Meanwhile, the security situation in the country has deteriorated sharply.
Dramatic ripple effects
The conflicts in Mali and in north-east Nigeria have major consequences for many countries in the Sahel region and around the Lake Chad Basin. The security situation in Mali deteriorated further in 2018 and violence has spread from the north to more central parts of the country. Many refugees are too scared to return home. Meanwhile, many fear that the conflict will become protracted and that it will grow worse in 2019.
The armed conflict in north-east Nigeria, which continues to affect every country in the Lake Chad region, has created a humanitarian crisis for a population that is also facing a number of challenges such as extreme poverty, climate change, chronic food shortages, the uprising of several armed insurgents, and organised crime.
There are no short-term solutions for the challenges in this part of the Sahel belt and the areas around the Lake Chad Basin, and people will continue to bear the brunt of violence in 2019. Humanitarian assistance must be prioritised to a much greater extent, and long-term assistance must have a clear focus.
Without international support, many countries in the Sahel will not be able to meet the UN sustainability goals, and thousands more will be forced to flee.
Critical in Cameroon
Cameroon plays an important role in this vulnerable region, both politically and in terms of humanitarian assistance, with its strategic location in the Sahel border region. The country houses more than 350,000 refugees from neighbouring Nigeria and CAR, while violence caused by the Islamist rebel group Boko Haram has forced 228,000 Cameroonians to the border areas to Nigeria. Cameroon’s stability is now increasingly threatened by its internal conflicts.
Meanwhile, the unrest in the English-speaking areas of south-west and north-west Cameroon has been on the rise after talks between government and opposition groups broke down in 2017. In the autumn of 2018, 437,000 Cameroonians were displaced in these areas, while 30,000 fled across the border to Nigeria and became refugees. There is a great risk that violence will surge in 2019.
The Central African Republic (CAR) is the world’s third worst humanitarian crisis, after Yemen and Syria, based on the proportion of people dependent on humanitarian aid. One in four Cameroonians have been forced to flee. Still, in November 2018, humanitarian organisations lacked over half of the funds needed to provide people with lifesaving assistance, while the peacekeeping force MINUSCA was underfinanced.
Without fresh funding, one of the world’s worst humanitarian crises will continue to wreak havoc in 2019.
Optimism in the Horn of Africa
When Eritrea and Ethiopia signed a peace agreement in July 2018, hope spread across the Horn of Africa, one of Africa’s most conflict-affected regions. Now, sanctions against Eritrea will be lifted, and the ripple effects may grow to be significant – thousands of families divided by the conflict have already been reunited.
However, lifting travel restrictions between the two countries has also seen a rise in asylum seekers to Ethiopia in the autumn of 2018. But increased stability and hope of reform in Eritrea give us reason to hope the number of Eritreans embarking on the dangerous journey across the Mediterranean will decline in the future.
The accelerating democracy process in Ethiopia may also, in the long term, provide hope for solutions to the country’s own conflicts. It’s urgent. No other country in the world has seen higher internal displacement this year than Ethiopia, according to NRC’s Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre’s mid-year report.
In the autumn of 2018, violence and conflict led to hundreds of thousands of new displaced people. It is now very important that the international community step up their efforts to provide sufficient assistance. If the positive side effects of the peace agreement are not maintained, the political and humanitarian costs can be extremely high.
An uncertain peace in South Sudan
More than four million South Sudanese, one third of the population, have been forced to flee over the last five years. The peace agreement signed by President Salva Kiir, rebel leader Riek Machar and other armed opposition forces in September 2018 spurred hope, but many displaced people still fear that violence could explode again. South Sudan enters 2019 with hope, but first and foremost with uncertainty.
Less to those who welcome many
In East Africa, support to humanitarian assistance in key host countries such as Uganda, Kenya and Tanzania, has been severely cut in 2018. Wealthy countries, who have an increasingly restrictive refugee policy, provide some support to those countries that still receive a large number of displaced people. The East African countries house two million refugees, while the total number arriving Europe is decreasing.
Continued crisis in Somalia and DR Congo
Also in Somalia, one of Africa’s protracted humanitarian crises, reduced support for humanitarian assistance has led to cuts in basic help such as food, water, health and education. The support has been cut in spite of increased conflict levels and new tens of thousands displaced people in the autumn of 2018.
The Democratic Republic of Congo topped NRC’s list of the world’s ten most neglected crises in 2018. The country has never before seen more displaced people. The number of people without enough food to eat has also doubled from 7.9 million in 2017 to over 15 million in 2018.
The awarding of the Nobel Peace Prize 2018 to Congolese gynaecologist Denis Mukwege will hopefully lead to an increased focus on the conflict’s invisible victims of sexual violence.
Europe - Fewer migrants and refugees
There have been far fewer refugees and migrants arriving Europe in 2018 compared to last year. The main reason for this is that it has become more difficult to get to Italy via the Mediterranean Sea route from Libya.
Italy is funding the Libyan coastguard, which now picks up most people trying to reach Italy and returns them to detention camps in Libya, where they are left in inhumane conditions. Italy has also refused boats with refugees and migrants to dock. In the first ten months of 2018, only 22,000 took the sea route to Italy, compared to 111,000 in 2017.
The western Mediterranean Sea route through Morocco to Spain is now the main route to Europe with 50,000 arrivals by October 2018, over twice as many as last year.
The conflict between government forces and separatists in eastern Ukraine has been ongoing since 2014. Here, 3.5 million people are in need of humanitarian assistance.
Displaced people lack shelter and other necessities of life, and prolonged displacement makes it particularly necessary to find lasting solutions. There have been no signs of an immediate solution, and in November, the situation deteriorated sharply when Russia took control of Ukrainian naval vessels in a strategic area by the Black Sea.
As winter is approaching, many are worried – what will happen next?
The Middle East - Continuing political unrest, war and mass displacement
Uncertain return to Syria
The conflict in Syria has led to the biggest refugee crisis of our time. Although the government took control of a number of areas in 2018, the lack of security and major destructions mean that the humanitarian crisis is far from over. More than six million people are still displaced inside the country. Despite a political agreement that prevented an escalation of violence in Idlib, people continue to live in uncertainty.
Some refugees have spontaneously returned to Syria, but there is a growing concern that worsening conditions for refugees residing in neighbouring countries will force more people to return home early to unsafe areas.
The support to neighbouring countries, which host millions of Syrian refugees, must continue in 2019, to prevent Syrians from having to return home before it is safe to do so.
Iraq in ruins after IS group
On 9 December 2017, the Iraqi Prime Minister declared that the war against the Islamic State group was over and won. A year later, however, 1.8 million people are still internally displaced in Iraq, while 8 million are in need of humanitarian assistance.
Although more than four million Iraqis have returned home, many of them live in the ruins left by IS. In cities like Mosul and Ramadi, there is an immediate need to rebuild houses, schools and hospitals to allow displaced people to return home safely. In some places like Sinjar, the reconstruction process has barely started. The city is in ruins, with no functioning schools or hospitals. More than 200,000 Yazidis are still displaced with no home to return to.
Awarding the Nobel Peace Prize for 2018 to the Yazidi woman, Nadia Murad, has helped to give the Yazidis a voice. It is also a contribution to the fight against the use of sexual violence as a weapon in war and conflict. It sheds lights on the need for victims to access justice across Iraq, and for perpetrators of violence to be held accountable for their actions.
National and local reconciliation efforts, supported by the international community, are also needed to help address community, ethno-religious, and tribal tensions that have been exacerbated by the conflict with IS. These are essential steps that must be undertaken to ensure Iraq’s path to stability and a recovery process in 2019.
2018: A disastrous year for Yemen
This year has been devastating for the people of Yemen. Over 22 million are in need of assistance, and thousands of civilians have been injured or killed. At the end of 2018, the population is continuing to suffer through one of the worst famines we have ever seen.
Violence, blockades of ports, the collapse of the labour market and an economy in freefall mean that millions of Yemenis are on the brink of hunger as the year comes to an end. The survival and security of millions of Yemenis now depend on the negotiations between the parties of the conflict, which took place in Sweden in December. A minimum outcome must be that all parties promise to abide by international law and refrain from war tactics that increase civilian suffering.
Asia - Afghanistan and Myanmar stand out
Civil war, drought and hunger in Afghanistan
The security situation has deteriorated in large parts of Afghanistan, and the parliamentary elections in October 2018 became one of the country’s bloodiest. In July, large areas were affected by drought, and in the period up to November 2018 the combination of conflict, drought and hunger forced 266,000 people to flee.
Hundreds of thousands of refugees are forced to return to the war-torn country from neighbouring countries. Seven in 10 of those returning become displaced again, according to an NRC report.
The Rohingya are too scared to return home
In June 2018, Myanmar and the UN signed a letter of intent on the return of around 700,000 Rohingya refugees in neighbouring Bangladesh. Its goal was to ensure a “voluntary, safe, dignified and sustainable” return for the refugees.
According to the UN, the Rohingya are one of the world’s most persecuted minorities. Destroyed villages and a rhetoric of hate mean that many people of the Muslim minority are too scared to return home. Nevertheless, this was not the first time a return agreement was signed.
In November 2017, Myanmar and Bangladesh signed an agreement to start returning the Rohingya refugees. However, in October 2018, Bangladeshi authorities stated that the refugees refused to accept voluntary return because their villages were destroyed, and they were worried about what would happen to them if they went back.
Central America - Extreme violence forces thousands to flee
In Latin America, three crises are emerging, taking place in parts of Central America, Venezuela and Colombia. In Central America, organised crime, violence and poverty have for several years forced people to leave their home country. This is especially serious in El Salvador, Guatemala and Honduras, also known as the Northern Triangle.
Although more people are seeking asylum in Mexico, Belize, Costa Rica and Panama, there are still many who continue north to the United States, a country that has sharply tightened its asylum policy. At the end of November 2018, US police clashed with migrants who attempted to cross the border.
President Trump is trying to change the law so that migrants and asylum seekers cannot enter the country before they have received their asylum applications, while Mexico has asked the UN for help to prevent a humanitarian crisis. By December 2018, over 67,000 Hondurans who escaped from violence and poverty had returned from the United States and Mexico.
The problems in Central America are complex and will take time to solve. Of the world’s 50 most violent cities, 42 are in Latin America. The combination of weak state institutions, corruption, organised crime, extreme social inequality and violence is an explosive cocktail. There’s no quick fix here, and in 2019, the United States and Mexico will play key roles in dealing with these challenges.
Humanitarian crisis in Venezuela and a fragile peace in Colombia
Venezuela’s humanitarian crisis deteriorated in 2018. Thousands of people fled the country daily in 2018, often to neighbouring countries Colombia, Brazil, Ecuador and Peru. In November 2018, the government finally accepted humanitarian assistance from the UN.
Most of the people who leave Venezuela cross the border to neighbouring Colombia, a country that is going through a demanding peace process. When Iván Duque of the right-wing party, Centro Democratico, won the presidential election in June 2018, he aimed to change the peace agreement with FARC, which caused frustration among demobilised guerrilla soldiers. A lack of trust between the conflict parties has created a fragile peace. In the last six months of 2018, social leaders have been murdered and armed groups have displaced civilians as they try to take over former FARC-controlled areas.
Another negative trend is the large increase in coca production. Lack of security also means that many displaced people are worried about returning home. A peace agreement between the ELN group and a number of demobilised FARC soldiers is also yet to come. As the latter are leaving the demobilisation camps, their rivals are picking up arms. Although FARC leaders are adhering to the peace agreement, increasing dissatisfaction puts it under pressure.
It’s important that the peace agreement in Colombia and its intentions be respected in 2019. The situation in the country requires reconciliation, not polarisation.
As we enter 2019, displacement crises are still lining up. Emergency aid and political will to resolve conflicts are essential in order to relieve the suffering of people forced to flee all over the world.
Visit the related web page
View more stories|