People's Stories Democracy

View previous stories


Ten Years of Australian Prime Minister John Howard
by The Age & agencies
Australia
 
March 2006
 
John Howard: an ordinary bloke who feeds a nation"s prejudices, by Hugh Mackay. (The Age)
 
As he celebrates his 10th anniversary in the top job, John Howard"s grip on the prime ministership appears firmer than ever. No challenger, on either side of politics, comes close to Howard in terms of the respect he enjoys in the Australian electorate.
 
Respect? For the man who misled us over the children overboard affair; the man who created the infamous distinction between core and non-core promises; the man who used $4 million of taxpayers" money to pay outstanding entitlements to the employees of a failed company of which his brother happened to be chairman?
 
Respect? For the man who created an admirable set of standards of ministerial propriety and then revised them downwards rather than sack a mate; the man who sent Australian troops to invade Iraq, based on false information about Saddam"s non-existent weapons of mass destruction; the man who never seems to know anything about the kind of scandals (such as the corrupt wheat deals) that would once have had any responsible minister hanging his head in shame, if not actually resigning?
 
Yes, respect. The grounds for it have changed in the past decade, as earlier perceptions of a kind of gritty integrity have given way to a colder, more pragmatic view of Howard. Yet Howard"s reputation with Australian voters still rests more on respect than any other single factor. We may not like him; we may find it hard to know when he is telling the truth; yet we respect him.
 
Even the many disillusioned voters who no longer trust Howard speak of their respect for the man"s dogged persistence, his economic credentials, his political cleverness and his powerful instinct for survival.
 
Howard is widely perceived as the ultimate pragmatist, the arch politician, "the safe pair of hands", the man to weather a crisis, national or personal, without ever appearing to flinch. And in spite of all our disappointment and disillusionment - and, in extreme cases, our disgust and despair - we continue to respect him for those qualities.
 
When he came to office, Howard made two remarks that have turned out to be prophetic. He declared that "the times suit him" and he spoke of his wish for Australians to be "relaxed and comfortable" under his prime ministership. Against the odds - odds that range from a dizzying rate of change to the threat of international terrorism - many Australians have indeed found a way to be relaxed and comfortable (though, ironically, many have achieved that only by turning their backs on Howard"s political circus).
 
The key to Howard"s appeal lies in his very lack of charisma. His appearance of ordinariness is perhaps his greatest political asset: he looks and sounds like "an ordinary bloke" and that triggers the almost instinctive feeling that he must be "a decent bloke" as well. Even his harshest critics, people who believe he has actually lied to them, remark that he does it so convincingly and appears so sincere, it"s hard not to be seduced.
 
Howard acts like one of us. His personal standards are no higher than ours. Although we might yearn for visionary and charismatic leaders, there"s something peculiarly reassuring about a bloke in whom we recognise our own frailties, weaknesses and contradictions.
 
Some leaders inspire us with the noble idea that we might create a better society; Howard sets our sights on a lower, lesser target. Far from inspiring nobility of purpose, he encourages us to be comfortable with some of the baser aspects of our own ordinariness.
 
He reinforces our materialism. By conflating politics with economics and by placing emphasis on material prosperity, Howard has encouraged the idea that money is the key to happiness, that share-ownership is a symbol of success and that the rich should be praised and rewarded for being rich.
 
That, in turn, reinforces our moral laxity, partly because that"s the usual result of an over-emphasis on material values. Howard"s unwavering commitment to the strategy of "toughing it out" also encourages, by example, our thoroughly human tendency to be self-serving and, when it suits our purposes, dishonest.
 
He reinforces our prejudices. From the moment he appeared to align himself with Pauline Hanson"s sympathisers, Howard has been the master of so-called "dog-whistle" politics - giving people permission to indulge their prejudices without ever quite saying so. Under Howard, we have become less compassionate, less tolerant and more uninhibited in the expression of ethnic and religious prejudice. "Terrorist" has become a convenient new cloak for some very old prejudices.
 
Howard hasn"t done any of this single-handedly, of course: we have been his partners in this entire enterprise. It is in his ability to reinforce what is already there - dark as it may be -that the true genius of Howard"s prime ministership lies.
 
(Hugh Mackay is a social commentator).
 
The past decade has felt like a century, by Phillip Adams.
 
As a general rule of the political thumb, the greatest battles are within political parties rather than between them. You"ve only to look at the fratricidal conflicts fought by Labor factions or at the bitter disunity within the Blair Government in Britain.
 
The same applies to religions. Who needs that clash of civilisations between Christians and Muslims when fractures in a single faith are more than enough to get the blood flowing?
 
Exhibits A through F: decades of murderous conflict between Catholic and Protestant in Northern Ireland, the theological thuggery that destroys both the dignity and decency of the Sydney diocese of the Anglican church, the Rwandan-style butchery perpetrated by one Muslim group against another in Darfur and the civil war brewing between Sunni and Shia in Iraq. And don"t forget the conflicts between the ultra-orthodox and their less fundamentalist co-religionists in Israel.
 
Far lower on the Richter scale of national upheavals but nonetheless significant is the fissure that runs through Australian political and social life. And this is its 10th birthday. A decade ago was the first appearance of a hairline fracture that has become, for many, an abyss.
 
On one side stand the Howard huggers, jumping up and down in their joy and triumphalism. On the other, looking so glum and defeated that they might at any moment hurl themselves off the cliff, are the Howard haters, an odd alliance of old lefties, progressive liberals and Peter Costello.
 
As an unapologetic member of this latter group who has always argued that Howard is as bad a PM as Bush is a president, I am still happily celebrating this political milestone – because it marks the approaching end of the Howard millstone.
 
We will rejoice like slaves freed at the end of the US Civil War (another example of the internecine battle); like the Israelites escaping Egypt. Even if our coalition enemies are not drowned like Pharaoh"s army (though the rising sea levels caused by the Howard/Bush refusal to sign the Kyoto climate change treaty might arrive just in time to sink them), we will know that at long last, after 10 years in the wilderness, we"re at least approaching the Promised Land. A land without Howard.
 
That"s why we Howard haters are popping the corks along with the Howard huggers. For at least we"re 10 years closer to Howard"s departure from the Lodge and Kirribilli than we were in 1996. Of course, 3650-odd days ago none of us in our wildest nightmares could have imagined that the menace of his mendacity and militant mediocrity would last more than a single term. But we hadn"t factored in Howard"s cunning and his luck, or Labor"s suicidal stupidities and Kim Beazley"s blunderings.
 
I won"t waste space listing yet again Howard"s sins of commission, omission and emission (all that political flatulence adding to the greenhouse gases) because, of course, the Howard huggers have applauded them all. They"ve clapped the monstrous maltreatment of asylum-seekers, cheered Howard"s repeated playing of the race card, given standing ovations to our involvement in the greatest military fiasco since Vietnam and acclaimed our descent into a bleaker, harder-hearted society. This latter phenomenon is identified in the latest polls where citizens (sorry, customers) acknowledge Howard"s Australia is increasingly mean-spirited. But that"s OK. While ashamed of what Australia has become, they still approve of his performance as PM. It"s the economy, stupid!
 
Opposing the Howard huggers, in the coalition of the unwilling huddling on the other side of the abyss, are Liberals horrified by what Howard has done to their party, let alone theircountry. Among their numbers are Howard"s predecessors in the Liberal leadership, ministers either shown the door or resigning, some of them their party membership, and those progressives either opposed or deposed in preselection fights every bit as nasty as Labor"s.
 
What we"ve witnessed, what we"ve lived through, wasn"t a historic inevitability. It was an accident of history. Remember that both the Howard and Bush years were the result of electoral photo finishes.
 
For both men, first-term victories came despite losing the popular vote. Leave aside the chicanery in Florida and the coup d"etat of the stacked Supreme Court, Bush"s victory in 2000 could have been prevented by a slightly better performance by Al Gore and the Democrats. Ditto for Labor and Kim Gore. Beazley"s verbosities and tactics were eerily like Al"s. Labor could have won if Kim had really wanted to.
 
But now that we"re 10 years closer to the end of Howard, let us acknowledge that it will take another 10 to repair the damage, to restore the spirit we were celebrating at the approach of the centenary of federation. And when we welcomed the world and its athletes to the Sydney Olympics.
 
Remember those days? When we"d finally put White Australia to rest? When we could talk proudly about our tolerance? Ten years? Seems more like a hundred.
 
The success of the politics of division, by Kenneth Davidson.
 
How often do we hear from the Liberals in response to some felt community need that there is no point in "throwing more money at it" or rationalising cutbacks in some Hawke/Keating government welfare program by arguing that it wasn"t effective because it was "middle-class welfare"?
 
Overwhelmingly, the charge of public largesse and middle-class welfare is false. The main reason Australia has low taxes and low welfare spending compared with most OECD countries is because welfare is rigorously means-tested in Australia.
 
This is why the so-called tax reform debate is so mean-spirited. The middle class resents paying taxes to fund residual public health, education and welfare services they would not use in a fit.
 
By contrast, in industrialised Europe, services are universally provided on the insurance principle. European voters know that politicians promising tax cuts are politicians promising to cut expenditure on their education, health and welfare services.
 
Prime Minister John Howard"s aspirationals believe - with some justice - that tax cuts for them mean expenditure cuts on education, health and welfare for the improvident or poor who will not or cannot afford the superior private (heavily subsidised) alternative.
 
There is no mystery about Howard"s political success. The times and circumstances suit Howard. Globally, economic growth has been 12 per cent higher over the past 10 years than the previous 20 and most of the additional wealth has been channelled into an asset price bubble via a distorted tax system instead of nation-building infrastructure.
 
The "long boom" will continue for as long as the rest of the world is prepared to accumulate United States (and Australian) dollar debts in return for Chinese (and Japanese, South Korean and Taiwanese) export surpluses.
 
The reason for the slower growth in the period up to 1996 was that previous governments in the US (and Australia) believed external balance was important and were prepared to dampen domestic demand to achieve it.
 
Treasurer Peter Costello"s 1996 election foreign debt truck was put away immediately after the election, never to be seen again. There is now more concern about US foreign liabilities than Australia"s, even though net foreign liabilities in relation to GDP are about 30 per cent in the US and 60 per cent in Australia. We are in the hands of our creditors. The US has sufficient muscle to cut a deal with China. Australia hasn"t. The spectre haunting the Howard Government is the possibility that a financial crisis could wipe out the capital gains of the aspirationals overnight.
 
In the meantime, we have more exciting things to debate - like the size of the tax cut in the May budget - while Howard"s beneficiaries maintain a po-faced belief that tax cuts (for them) are the way of sound economic reform.
 
The structural fissures that have been opened up by this Government - the politicised public service, the under-funded public schools, universities, TAFEs, the ABC and CSIRO and public hospitals, plus the privatisation of Telstra, which has shifted its direction from nation-building to profit maximisation - are celebrated as evidence of sound financial management, though the fissures must be repaired if the external financial balance is to be corrected.
 
Everything is grist to the mill of financial capitalism, which has now escaped effective political control through the privatisation of pensions financed by compulsory superannuation.
 
Privatised toll roads have become the most expensive way to undermine liveability in Melbourne and Sydney. Now the electorate is being softened up for the injection of private capital into water conservation.
 
Why? There is no shortage of capital or the ability of government to borrow more cheaply and invest more wisely in the public interest than bankers seeking private profit. The political mindset has changed. Political success used to depend on a perceived ability to manage national development. Now it depends on the ability to read the angst from focus groups in order to divide the community into "us" and "them".
 
The task of nation-building has been handed over to haute finance because the political process has been corrupted. Politicians are terrified that if they put the public interest ahead of private financial interests they will be branded financially and economically irresponsible.
 
The politics of division is a race to the bottom. Now Costello and others are seeking to play the race card, albeit sotto voce, for political advantage. Which politician is prepared to make the obvious point that the best long-term breeding ground for fundamentalism is fundamentalist schools, or military adventures that serve no real national purpose but cause collateral damage to social solidarity by inflaming ethnic tensions? This provides the excuse for government to suppress dissent with anti-democratic anti-terrorism and sedition laws that isolate "them" further and could even promote the terrorism they ostensibly attempt to prevent.
 
It has to be said that Howard is better at this game than any Labor leader in the past decade. But that won"t last forever. The so-called Labor renewal under way in Victoria may produce politicians with the requisite ruthlessness combined with the po-faced rectitude necessary to compete with Howard on his own favoured political terrain.


 


Gap between rich and poor widens in China
by IHT / BBC News & agencies
China
 
March 2006 (Reuters)
 
China’s parliament yesterday approved a plan to close the gap between urban rich and rural poor after one of the most robust debates over the pace of reform since the days of paramount leader Deng Xiaoping. This year"s parliamentary debate was not about whether to reform, but about the pace of liberalisation, with critics blaming reforms for rising social inequality.
 
Premier Wen Jiabao vowed to punish officials who forcibly seize the land of farmers, now a very common cause of grievance. "We will make sure we guarantee the long-term land rights of farmers," Mr Wen said. "We will maintain the strictest controls to prevent their land being forcibly taken away from them."
 
Earlier yesterday, about 3000 delegates to the National People"s Congress approved a five-year plan to tackle the wealth chasm dividing cities and the countryside. The plan was approved by party leaders last year. The rubber-stamp parliament has never voted down Communist Party policy.
 
Premier Wen opened parliament on March 5 pledging that China would channel its surging economic growth to narrow the gap between the rich and the poor.
 
That gap has been linked — with corruption, land grabs and other problems — to a rise in social unrest in the countryside, home to more than 700 million people who earn just a third of the annual wages of their urban brethren.
 
March 2006
 
China keeps them down on the farm, by Philip Bowring. (IHT)
 
Necessity as well as good sense lies behind China"s decision in its latest five year plan, revealed at the National People"s Congress, to play down numerical growth goals and target instead the wealth gap and social and environmental issues. But the new goals look likely to be out of reach without more fundamental policy changes to address rural poverty.
 
The shift away from numerical targets makes political sense because growth will probably be significantly slower, at least for the next two or three years, than the 9 percent it has averaged over the past five years.
 
There are likely to be significant declines in growth of investment, as recent excesses are reflected in overcapacity and falling profits, and declines in exports, as deficit countries - mainly the United States - finally face up to their trade imbalances.
 
Labor force growth will also decline and efforts to address environmental problems by reducing air pollution and using less water will cut headline growth rates even as they improve public health and economic sustainability.
 
The government"s own spending plans will also have an impact on growth. First, defense spending, which has few multiplier effects, is rising. Second, more money will be pumped into rural areas - to improve education and infrastructure and, hopefully, raise farm productivity. These investments are seen as socially necessary, but even if they produce the desired results, the returns will only be seen in the long term.
 
Few inside or outside China doubt that income gaps, particularly between rural and urban populations, have become so wide as to have become a threat to social stability. Abuse of power by local party officials to enrich themselves at the expense of the powerless has exacerbated the political dangers of the wealth divide. Meanwhile, much urban investment has been wasted on prestigious official buildings.
 
China has the good sense not to try to bolster farm incomes through price subsidies. They make little sense anywhere and can only be afforded by industrialized countries like the United States, Japan and the members of the European Union, where farmers are a small percentage of the work force.
 
Last year"s abolition of taxes on farmers has been a help and funds now promised for rural education will do something to narrow the schooling divide. But the amount of money that a fiscally conservative Beijing now proposes to push into these areas is unlikely to be enough to make a big difference, at least in the more populous of the poor regions.
 
China"s rural answer must be to raise rural productivity, which is indeed the official goal. But land productivity is already high in most of China, a factor reflected in the over-use of water resources. By far the surest way to reduce income disparities is to increase manpower productivity - which can only be done by moving underemployed workers to gainful employment, even at low wages, in the cities. Migration of rural labor has a double benefit, reducing the farm population and creating a stream of remittances back to the rural areas.
 
Although there is much greater freedom of movement than in the past, local regulations keep rural migrants out of some cities altogether and lack of access to social and educational services for migrant families is a major deterrent. This keeps urban wages, housing and other standards conspicuously high while leaving rural areas near destitution.
 
The favelas of Rio and the slums of Mumbai may be eyesores missing in Shanghai and Guangzhou, but they testify to freedom of movement of people which is still only partial in China. Indeed, though China"s urban economy has been growing at double digits, the pace of urbanization has been no faster than that of slower growing India.
 
China"s leaders remain more concerned with keeping its urban residents, and especially those of the major cities, in clover while the peasant majority - which put them into power in the first place - languishes.
 
The second major change that would raise rural productivity would be to give land title to the tillers. They could then borrow against it to increase mechanization, sell it to raise capital for small businesses, or provide cash to help them get started with a new life in the city. The consolidation of ownership that would result from a free market in land would itself raise productivity.
 
But no, a party that allows well- placed heads of state enterprises to become billionaires almost overnight and whose officials take land from the cultivators for sale for urban property development nevertheless sticks to its historical "socialist principles" when it comes to farmers and their land. China"s ruling party has given a new rural twist to Orwell"s fable of the corruption of Communist power, "Animal Farm." Fundamental policy changes, not just tweaks in state budgeting, are needed.Independent trade unions don"t exist in China.
 
March 2006
 
China pledges help for rural poor. (BBC News)
 
China"s key annual political event has opened, with the government promising to take measures to close the divide between the new rich and numerous poor.
 
Premier Wen Jiabao addressed 3,000 delegates at the National People"s Congress in Beijing. He predicted China"s economy would grow by 8% this year and by an average of 7.5% over the next four years.
 
He promised extra money for rural areas and farmers, to spread growing wealth to the impoverished countryside. "Building a "new socialist countryside" is a major historic task," Mr Wen told the conference.
 
As the conference got under way, thousands of security personnel swarmed around Tiananmen Square, which was blocked off to the public. Protesters were prevented from reaching the area.
 
He said the government plans to spend 340bn yuan ($42bn; £24bn) this year upgrading agriculture, and billions more on rural social services.
 
The government is concerned about growing rural unrest as the hundreds of millions of rural poor are left behind by China"s surging urban economy. Its own figures report 87,000 protests and other incidents of discontent last year.
 
The "new socialist countryside" is the buzz phrase in the Communist Party at the moment, says the BBC"s Rupert Wingfield-Hayes in Beijing.
 
Tackling rural tensions is a priority, as there is a sense that if they continue to grow they could pose a major threat to Chinese stability. "Some deeply seated conflicts that have accumulated over a long time have yet to be fundamentally resolved, and new problems have arisen that cannot be ignored," Mr Wen said. China must "pay more attention to social equity and social stability so that all the people can enjoy the fruits of reform and development".
 
March 2006
 
Rural Chinese hope for a Harvest, by Mary-Anne Toy.
 
Chineses Annual Congress must balance demands from the poor and 125 million youths looking for work.
 
It’s easy to tell when China"s equivalent of Parliament begins its annual sitting, which it will do tomorrow.
 
Beijing explodes in traditional pageantry as 3000 or so delegates from across the country converge on Tiananmen Square — and hundreds of unfortunate dissidents get rounded up.
 
Usually the costumes worn by ethnic minority delegates are the most colourful part of the annual National People"s Congress, which is effectively a rubber-stamping of decisions already negotiated. This year, however, a steady stream of propaganda in the lead-up to the Congress — about how worried China"s leaders are about the wealth gap between peasants and city dwellers — has built expectations of real improvement to the lives of the three-quarters of the people who still live on the land.
 
President Hu Jintao, Prime Minister Wen Jiabao and other Government officials have talked loudly and often in the past month of the urgent need to improve healthcare, education and incomes in rural areas, tackle pollution, and for land seizures to be performed lawfully to maintain stability.
 
There have been suggestions that party chiefs from well-off, largely eastern provinces are not thrilled at the prospect of diverting large amounts of money to impoverished cousins in the rural west and inner China, but in the poorest provinces such as Guizhou, local government officials are eagerly awaiting a windfall from Beijing as the Government makes good on its rhetoric about building a "new socialist countryside".
 
Social works, however, face strong competition from other sectors, such as the military, which is set to get its third straight year of double-digit budget increases as China seeks to modernise its big but, in many respects, ill-equipped and outdated armed forces. The country"s renewed efforts in space exploration and its recent commitment to technological and scientific innovation won"t come cheap either.
 
Arthur Kroeber, managing director of the Hong Kong-based economic research firm Dragonomics, says there are 125 million reasons to expect that despite the talk of greater social justice, growth will remain China"s top priority.
 
That"s the size of China"s biggest age group: 15 to 19-year-olds, most of whom will be needing jobs soon. Even with high growth, China is expecting 14 million unemployed, a million more than in 2005, according to official estimates.
 
"High growth remains the Government"s central priority because they"re at their maximum employment crunch time. It"s a demographic thing. "With 125 million people between 15 and 19 what are they going to do, say double or triple unemployment to be a little bit greener? No," Mr Kroeber said.
 
However, with per capita GDP at $US1400 ($A1900), China is rich enough to be able to divert more money into education and social services without slowing growth, Mr Kroeber says. But don"t expect to see radical improvements in the environment and equity until per capita GDP hits $US3000 — and that"s at least 10 years away, even with China"s astonishing growth rate.
 
President Hu Jintao has called for a focus on the countryside to help improve farmers" lives amid rising fears about the widening wealth gap and rural unrest.


 

View more stories

Submit a Story Search by keyword and country Guestbook