People's Stories Democracy

View previous stories


This misadventure has alienated most of the world from Bush
by Gary Younge
The Guardian
United Kingdom
 
March 20, 2006
 
Since going to war, the president has managed to make himself almost as unpopular with US voters as he is with Iraqis.
 
Shortly before the first Gulf war the recently retired chairman of the United States joint chiefs of staff, Admiral William Crowe, went for lunch with his successor, Colin Powell. In words that resonate today, Crowe warned Powell that "a war in the Middle East - killing thousands of Arabs for whatever noble purpose - would set back the US in the region for a long time. And that was to say nothing of the Americans who might die".
 
But despite his own misgivings, Crowe clearly believed military intervention was likely in the interests of presidential prestige.
 
"It takes two things to be a great president," he told Powell. "First you have to have a war. All the great presidents have had their wars. Two you have to find a war where you are attacked."
 
Six years into his presidency it is difficult to think of a single, substantial foreign policy initiative that US president George Bush has pursued that did not involve war, or the threat of it. There is good reason for this. It is the one area in which America reigns supreme, accounting alone for 40% of the global military expenditure and spending almost seven times the amount of its nearest rival, China.
 
Yet greatness eludes him. For if the last six years have proved anything, it is the limitations of military might as the central plank of foreign policy. Indeed, shorn of meaningful diplomacy or substantial negotiation, it has failed even on its own narrow, nationalistic terms of making America safer and securing its global hegemony. In short, in displaying his strength in such a brash, brazen, reckless and ruthless manner, Bush has asserted power and lost authority and influence both at home and abroad.
 
With his approval ratings at Nixonian lows and the mid-term elections on the horizon, many of his fellow Republicans regard him as a liability.
 
Stumbling across the political landscape, rallying support for lost causes, he resembles Ernest Harrowden in The Picture of Dorian Gray, a character whom Oscar Wilde described as "one of those middle-aged mediocrities, who have no enemies, but are thoroughly disliked by their friends".
 
Last week"s release of the national security strategy did not counter that trend but confirmed it. Insisting that diplomacy remains America"s "strong preference", it went on to reaffirm its commitment to pre-emption. "If necessary, under long-standing principles of self-defence, we do not rule out use of force before attacks occur," it states. Iran received special mention, with a warning that talks "must succeed if confrontation is to be avoided".
 
In practice this translates into a per perverse version of carrot-and-stick diplomacy. Offer your adversary a carrot and then threaten to whack them with the stick while they are eating it.
 
That America"s standing has plummeted with this approach is without question. Of the 10 countries polled in 2000 and again in 2005 by the Pew research group, the US had fallen in people"s estimation in eight of them. In only three - Canada, Britain and Russia - did a majority still look upon the US favourably. It"s not difficult to see why.
 
Last week the country that aspires to lead the free world stood alongside only Israel, Palau and the Marshall Islands and against 170 countries in rejecting the creation of a new UN council to protect human rights. Only the US and Somalia (which has no recognised government) have failed to ratify the UN convention on the rights of the child.
 
So long as the US clung to the notion that military strength would always have the last say, none of this mattered. Like a band of demented Millwall supporters, the Bush administration could strut across the global stage chanting: "No one likes us, we don"t care". Indeed, in the first few years after 9/11 it wore its unpopularity like a badge of honour.
 
But as events in Iraq have soured, the ability of the Bush administration to deliver on these threats has diminished considerably. With its military overstretched and its diplomatic goodwill spent, it has been forced back to the table from a relative position of weakness, because nobody trusts it or particularly fears it. If anything, both Iran and North Korea have been emboldened by its failures in the Gulf.
 
Meanwhile, elections keep on producing the wrong results. Hamas is in power in Palestine; René Préval, the protege of Jean-Bertrand Aristide whom the US helped remove in a coup two years ago, won the presidency in Haiti; Ahmed Chalabi, the protege of the neocons whom the US wanted to impose on the Iraqi people at the outset of the war, could not win a single seat. Elsewhere, voters in Latin America have opted for leaders who campaigned against the neoliberal economic strictures imposed by Washington.
 
The issue is not whether the developing world is ready for democracy - as the administration keeps arguing - but if the US is ready for the democratic choices made by the developing world.
 
But the principle area where the US has demonstrated its military supremacy and its diplomatic weakness is Iraq. This misadventure has not only alienated most of the world from the administration, but increasingly alienated the two constituencies it really does need to win over - the Iraqis and the Americans. One of the key demands of the United Iraqi Alliance, the broadbased Shia coalition that won the elections in December, was the removal of the American military. Given that the Sunnis are leading the insurgency, this leaves few backers among the Iraqis.
 
And, simultaneously, support for the war in the US is haemorrhaging. A CNN/USA Today poll last week showed 60% of Americans believe it was a mistake to send troops to Iraq and disapprove of the way Bush is handling the war. More than half want to see the troops withdrawn within a year. Even three-quarters of the soldiers fighting in Iraq, according to another poll, believe the US should leave within a year.
 
These problems may in no small part be due to the fact that in invading Iraq, Bush fulfilled only half of Crowe"s criteria for a great presidency. Despite efforts to convince the world otherwise, the war for which he will be remembered - Iraq - had nothing to do with why the US was attacked on September 11. On its own, that would be a moral issue of lying to the public.
 
What has transformed it into a political problem is the dire situation on the ground in Iraq. The most important single factor that shapes Americans" attitudes to any war is whether they think America will win, explains Christopher Gelpi, an associate professor of political science at Duke University who specialises in public attitudes to foreign policy. Over the past year, the percentage of Americans who believe the US is "certain to win" has plummeted from 79% to 22%; those who are either certain it will not win or believe this to be unlikely have risen from 1% to 41%.
 
"They are in big trouble," explains Gelpi. "Bush"s speeches, even as late as December, managed to shore up public opinion a little bit. But what you can do with speeches at this point is pretty limited. It"s not even clear who"s listening."
 
Wrong war. Wrong strategy. Wrong president. Just plain wrong.


 


Questions continue to be raised over Bush Presidency
by Washington Post / Boston Globe / Toronto Star..
USA
 
Washington. March 11, 2006
 
Bid to Give Bush the Boot, by Tim Harper. (The Toronto Star)
 
Residents of a small Vermont town have joined forces in a growing fight to impeach the U.S. president.
 
When the townsfolk gathered in the tiny Vermont community of Newfane for their annual meeting, the agenda was daunting. There was the town budget to be approved, then the school budget, plus they needed to approve spending $50,000 on the town"s property reappraisal.
 
And, oh yeah. Move to impeach the president of the United States.
 
And so, at the end of a five-hour meeting, the assembled were asked to consider: "Whereas George W. Bush has:
 
"1. Misled the nation about Iraq"s weapons of mass destruction;
 
"2. Misled the nation about ties between Iraq and Al Qaeda;
 
"3. Used these falsehoods to lead our nation into war unsupported by international law;
 
"4. Not told the truth about American policy with respect to the use of torture; and
 
"5. Directed the government to engage in domestic spying, in direct contravention of U.S. law;
 
"Therefore, the voters of the town of Newfane ask that our representative to the U.S. House of Representatives file articles of impeachment to remove him from office."
 
All in favour?: 129. All opposed?: 21. Meeting adjourned.
 
For a president on the run, cratering at record-low approval ratings, losing battles with Republicans who are beginning to consider him toxic, seemingly having lost his political stride like an aging slugger who can"t catch up to the fastball, impeachment is likely the least of his worries.
 
More worrisome for Bush is the perception he is so insulated during this second term that he has lost touch with the concerns of the nation, that he is still surrounded by the same top aides in notorious "burnout" positions who came to power with him five years ago, that the "trust me" president has squandered that trust.
 
But as a barometer of discontent with the second-term Bush presidency in a mid-term election year, the fact that impeachment has moved from angry bumper stickers to dinner party discussion is telling.
 
Democrats in Congress, probably quite wisely, won"t touch the question.
 
Michigan"s John Conyers introduced a resolution last December requesting an impeachment inquiry to deal with Bush"s "manipulation" of pre-war intelligence, but only 26 of 201 House Democrats backed him.
 
But that hasn"t stopped others. ImpeachPAC.org has endorsed and raised funds for three Democrats who vow to push for impeachment if elected in November"s mid-terms.
 
The organization, led by Democrat Bob Fertik is an offshoot of AfterDowningStreet.org, founded by David Swanson, a former reporter and press secretary who tried to mobilize opposition to Bush after the release of internal memos from the Tony Blair government indicated the White House was intent on crafting the conditions for an invasion of Iraq.
 
Newfane is one of nine U.S. communities, all in Vermont and California, to pass impeachment resolutions, the largest of which was San Francisco where city supervisors voted 7-3 for impeachment, saying Bush has destroyed civil liberties in his wiretapping program, and failed miserably in his response to Hurricane Katrina.
 
Lewis Lapham, the outgoing editor of Harper"s magazine and one of the country"s most outspoken Bush critics, makes the case for impeachment in the March issue of his magazine.
 
It includes this indictment: "We have before us in the White House a thief who steals the country"s good name and reputation for his private interest and personal use; a liar who seeks to instil in the American people a state of fear; a televangelist who engages the United States in a never-ending crusade against all the world"s evil; a wastrel who squanders a vast sum of the nation"s wealth on what turns out to be a recruiting drive certain to multiply the host of our enemies. "In a word, a criminal — known to be armed and shown to be dangerous."
 
Dan DeWalt, the 49-year-old Vermont woodworking teacher, furniture restorer and musician who introduced the Newfane resolution, says he wants to make impeachment a household word.
 
"We can"t take up arms against our government, so we do what we can," he said."If we stand by and do nothing, we would be complicit in the immoral and illegal activities of the administration. If you do nothing, you are acting illegally and immorally yourself."
 
The litany of high crimes and misdemeanours in this grim era for Bush are well known. It started shortly after his re-election, at a time when he was crowing about his "political capital" and there was talk of a conservative dynasty in the U.S. But when he spent much of that capital on an overhaul of Social Security, he found it couldn"t be sold, even within his own party.
 
Then came the CIA leak investigation, a probe that clearly distracted the White House, ending with the indictment of Lewis "Scooter" Libby, a top aide to Vice-President Dick Cheney. It was during this period that it became clear the political radar on Pennsylvania Ave. was down. His nomination of White House legal counsel Harriet Miers to the Supreme Court foundered against opposition from the right and ultimately had to be withdrawn.
 
His laggardly response to last year"s Hurricane Katrina became a case study of an administration asleep at the switch, bolstered by the recent release of video showing a seemingly disinterested Bush being briefed on the looming catastrophe.
 
Since December, when it was revealed in The New York Times, Bush has been fighting to justify a wiretapping program that has been denounced as illegal.
 
There was the tragicomedy shooting of a hunting pal by Dick Cheney, a gun mishap that turned into a week-long crisis for the White House.
 
That was quickly followed by the Dubai ports controversy. Whether the deal should have been killed may be open to debate, but again the political skills of this White House were tucked away and the ensuing groundswell of opposition to turning port management over to a company from the United Arab Emirates left Bush belatedly sputtering about using his veto to keep the deal alive.
 
By week"s end, he was in full retreat, having been stared down by a Republican congressional delegation which outflanked him on his vaunted strong suit, national security.
 
"They didn"t see it coming," said New York Republican Representative Peter King who led opposition to the deal. He told reporters in New York Bush administration officials have "got to get their antenna up much more on issues and bring the issues up in Congress. They need to realize we"re now entering into a complex state of a post-9/11 world."
 
Against all this, is a war in Iraq nearing its third anniversary with an AP-Ipsos poll released yesterday indicating 80 per cent of Americans - including 70 per cent of Republicans - believe Iraq is heading to civil war.
 
They call it the six-year itch, the second-term cloud that seems to inevitably envelop any president who doesn"t need to be elected.
 
Second-term presidents have dealt with sex scandals (Bill Clinton), out-of-control wars (Lyndon Johnson, Harry Truman), arms scandals (Ronald Reagan) and political scandals (Richard Nixon).
 
But only Nixon has had approval ratings as low as Bush"s 38 per cent average on a series of polls released last week.
 
The mystery in Washington is why Bush will not inject some new blood into his inner circle. Chief of staff Andrew Card and deputy chief of staff and political strategist Karl Rove have been with him since day one.
 
"You can lose your political instincts, you become less sensitive to the political cross-currents," says presidential historian Robert Dallek. "When you are falling on your face, faltering, stumbling around, it becomes all the more important to move the deck chairs around and bring in some fresh perspective and some fresh hope, plus a little renewed confidence for the country."
 
Larry Sabato, a political analyst at the University of Virginia, says Bush has faced some big "screw-ups" that have cost him. "The question on the street, from people who are not necessarily political, is whether the president is competent," he says.
 
09 March 2006
 
Culture of Intellectual Corruption, by Richard Cohen. (Washington Post)
 
It will be nearly impossible in the next several months to avoid the phrase "culture of corruption." It is of Democratic vintage, coined to take the sins of Jack Abramoff, former Rep. Randy "Duke" Cunningham and maybe some others and visit them on all Republicans running for office, especially congressional incumbents. Strictly speaking, it"s a bit of a smear. But if it applies anywhere, and it does, it"s not to corruption having to do with money, it"s to corruption having to do with thought. The Bush administration is intellectually corrupt.
 
Some of this corruption is induced by the inability to keep religion in its place. The president suffers mightily from this. After just eight months in office, George Bush drew a line between acceptable and unacceptable stem cell research and based it entirely on religious views that had nothing to do with science. Destruction of the cells was likened, as so much is nowadays, to the supposedly overriding issue of abortion or, as it is sometimes put, the "culture of life."
 
That culture, as applied by the Bush administration, holds that what works is what ought to work. So, for example, the official policy of the United States government is the promotion of sexual abstinence (outside of marriage), which is all right in and of itself but not as a substitute for a workable policy of population control and HIV-AIDS avoidance. The latter should entail sex education and, of course, the use of some sort of contraceptive device, particularly (for AIDS prevention) condoms. The Bush administration eschews that approach, exhorting the young and the randy just to eschew sex. That approach works until it does not. Then catastrophe hits.
 
Similarly, the Bush administration has somehow bottled up Plan B emergency contraception so that it is not yet available over the counter to women 17 and older. This is the case not because Plan B is dangerous or ineffective or even because it is an abortion agent (it is not), but because it is manifestly something that"s needed if abstinence is, somehow, not practiced. In other words, the scientific basis for this policy apparently comes down to this: A good girl should not need such a pill.
 
In the same way, the Bush administration for too long virtually insisted that there was no such thing as global warming. It has since changed its tune, conceding some of the case, but the epiphany has come late and not until additional damage was done both to the environment and, with the rejection of the Kyoto treaty, to America"s international standing. "On issues ranging from population control to the state of the environment, and from how science is taught in the classroom to whether Iraq"s research establishment was capable of producing weapons of mass destruction, the administration has repeatedly turned away from traditional avenues of scientific advice," writes Michael Specter in The New Yorker.
 
Specter is right to link Iraq with everything else, because the debacle there is a product of the same magical thinking that rejected global warming, stem cells and condoms alike. Underlying it all is a commitment to belief over fact, what should be over what is. It is evidenced in the insistence by Bush and others that "intelligent design" is, like evolution, worthy of teaching. "Both sides ought to be properly taught," Bush once said. Yes, and astronomy and astrology, too, and maybe chemistry and alchemy as well. It"s a totally bogus proposition.
 
It was a chat about a religious moment that purportedly bonded Bush to Vladimir Putin, the Russian leader of increasingly authoritian bent. It"s as if Putin, an ex-KGB spy, read Bush"s file - and conned him. He knew Bush would rather believe than think - and that others in the administration, who knew better, would simply go along.
 
Intellectual corruption has cost Americans more - much more - than the occasional crooked congressman or lobbyist. Maybe they represent a corrupt system - one in which the Democrats also partake - but they pale in significance to a neoconservative theory that took the country to war to face a threat that did not exist. In the war, as with stem cells, we are talking about unnecessary loss of life - right now on the battlefield, a bit later when the cure for some disease arrives later than it might have.
 
Corruption of any kind corrupts. It costs us either money or confidence or both. But intellectual corruption is far more dangerous. It ruins and costs lives.
 
March 9, 2006
 
At Last, US Neocons are beginning to face the facts they were Wrong, by Rupert Cornwell. (The Independent / UK)
 
It has taken more than three years, tens of thousands of Iraqi and American lives, and $200bn (£115bn) of treasure - all to achieve a chaos verging on open civil war. But, finally, the neo-conservatives who sold the United States on this disastrous war are starting to utter three small words. We were wrong.
 
The second thoughts have spread across the conservative spectrum, from William Buckley, editor of The National Review to Andrew Sullivan, once editor of the New Republic, now an influential commentator..For Mr Sullivan, today"s mess is above all a testament to American overconfidence and false assumptions, born of arrogance and naïveté. But he too asserts, in a column in Time magazine this week, that all may not be lost.
 
Of all the critiques however, the most profound is that of Francis Fukuyama, in his forthcoming book, America at the Crossroads. Its subtitle is "Democracy, Power and the Neo-Conservative Legacy" - and that legacy, Mr Fukuyama argues, is fatally poisoned.
 
This is no ordinary thesis, but apostasy on a grand scale. Mr Fukuyama, after all, was the most prominent intellectual who signed the 1997 "Project for the New American Century", the founding manifesto of neo-conservatism drawn up by William Kristol, editor of the Weekly Standard, the house journal of the neo-conservative movement.
 
The PNAC aimed to cement for all time America"s triumph in the Cold War, by increasing defence spending, challenging regimes that were hostile to US interests, and promoting freedom and democracy around the world. Its goal was "an international order friendly to our security, prosperity and values".
 
The war on Iraq, spuriously justified by the supposed threat posed by Saddam"s WMD, was the test run of this theory. It was touted as a panacea for every ill of the Middle East. The road to Jerusalem, the neo-cons argued, led through Baghdad. And after Iraq, why not Syria, Iran and anyone else that stood in Washington"s way? All that, Mr Fukuyama now acknowledges, has been a tragic conceit.
 
Like the Leninists of old, he writes, the neo-conservatives reckoned they could drive history forward with the right mixture of power and will. However, "Leninism was a tragedy in its Bolshevik version, and it has returned as farce when practiced by the United States."
 
But was it not Mr Fukuyama who claimed in his most celebrated work, The End of History and the Last Man, that the whole world was locked on a glide-path to liberal, free-market democracy? Yes indeed. But that book, he points out, argued that the process was gradual, and must unfold at its own pace.
 
But not only were the neo-cons too impatient. A second error was to believe that an all-powerful America would be trusted to exercise a "benevolent hegemony". A third was the gross overstatement of the post 9/11 threat posed by radical Islam, in order to justify the dubious doctrine of preventive war.
 
Finally, there was the blatant contradiction between the neo-cons" aversion to government meddling at home and their childlike faith in their ability to impose massive social engineering in foreign and utterly unfamiliar countries like Iraq. Thence sprang the mistakes of the occupation period..
 
The fact, however, remains that future Bush policymakers who signed the PNAC nine years ago are now mostly gone. Paul Wolfowitz, the war"s most relentless and starry-eyed promoter, has moved on to the World Bank, silent about the mess he did so much to create. Richard Perle, leader of the resident hawks department at the American Enterprise Institute think-tank here, has vanished from the scene. Lewis Libby meanwhile has stepped down as Vice-President Dick Cheney"s chief of staff, to focus his energy on staying out of jail.
 
Yet another signatory was Zalmay Khalilzad, now the US ambassador to Iraq. This week even he - Afghan born and the one original neo-con who had the region in his blood - admitted that the invasion had opened "a Pandora"s box" that could see the Iraq conflict spread across the entire Middle East.
 
Those left in the administration - primarily Mr Cheney and Donald Rumsfeld, the Defence Secretary, are not so much neo-conservatives as "Hobbesian unilateralists", concerned to protect and advance US national interests in a lawless and violent world, whatever it takes.
 
As for Condoleezza Rice, never a signed-up member of the movement but mostly sympathetic to it when she was the President"s security adviser - she has metamorphosed from hawk into pragmatist with her move from the White House to the State Department.
 
It is on George Bush"s lips that neo-conservatism most obviously survives - in the commitment to spreading freedom and democracy that he proclaims almost daily, and most hubristically in his second inaugural in 2005 that promised to banish tyranny from the earth.
 
But even the extravagant oratory of that icy January day cannot obscure the irony of America"s Iraq adventure. The application of a doctrine built upon the supposed boundlessness of US power has succeeded only in exposing its limits.
 
Thus chastened, Mr Fukuyama now wants to temper the idealism of the neo-conservative doctrine with an acceptance that some things are not so easy to change, and that the US must cut its cloth accordingly. He calls it "realistic Wilsonianism". A better description might be neo-realism..
 
06 March 2006
 
Bush, Lies, and Videotape, by James Carroll. (The Boston Globe)
 
If George W. Bush were a character in a novel or a play, last week might have been the turning point in the narrative. He was shown on film being explicitly warned, just hours before Hurricane Katrina hit, that the levees in New Orleans were vulnerable.
 
But everyone knows that after the levees broke, he denied having been warned that such a thing was possible. The broadcast of the film amounted to a terrible epiphany: The president seemed caught in a lie. Grave questions had already been raised about his administration"s manipulations of the truth, especially in relation to the war in Iraq. Does the truth matter in America any more?
 
Critics of the president (among whom I must be counted) might come to yet another swift judgment of him, finding further evidence of a disqualifying character flaw. Rumbles about impeachment can be heard, despite the unlikelihood of such an outcome, shy of Democratic victories in the fall elections.
 
But what if our concern with Bush was embedded in literature, not politics? In that case, the conflict we would care about is not the one between a public figure and his critics, but the struggle inside the man himself. Literature unfolds across an inner landscape, and on that terrain the character flaw is essential.
 
Indeed, the character flaw of the hero is what enables a reader or playgoer to identify with him, even while passing judgment. Last week"s videotape revelation raised public questions about the president"s truthfulness, but the private question - the one a man must face alone, in the crucible of conscience - is a version of the question we all must ask of ourselves.
 
Consider the possibilities. The fictional character - let"s call him "Bush" - learns that his firm public statement about what he had been told is radically contradicted by incontrovertible evidence. What he told the nation at its moment of crisis was not true, and that contradiction is now exposed.
 
Learning this, in one narrative line, "Bush" might feel deeply shamed to have laid bare what he has always known was a lie. The character flaw is deception. But in another narrative line, "Bush" might be shocked to realize that, in the traumatic moments of the hurricane crisis, he had blocked all memory of the critical briefing. He hadn"t consciously lied, but had constructed a new reality tailored to personal and political needs. The character flaw, in this case, is not deception, but self-deception.
 
Whatever "Bush" did in the past, however, the drama that matters adheres in what he does now, at the moment of being exposed. Whether "Bush" is a deceiver or a self-deceiver, the question is: What happens inside him at the terrible moment of judgment? In that instant, will he experience a transformation in awareness, as the truth of his condition shows itself? Or will he descend into a further circle of denial, deepening his predicament?
 
If this were a novel or a play, we would watch with a certain empathy, alert to revelations of our own inevitable implication in deception and self-deception. None of us is innocent, and it is to wrestle with that fact of our condition that we read books and buy theater tickets.
 
But the present American story is not a work of literature. From all appearances, the president is not a candidate for the role of "Bush" because a narrative that unfolds across the terrain of an inner life requires an inner life, and Bush shows no sign of having one.
 
Even a character flaw presumes a depth of character that the president seems to lack. What interior conflict can there be for a man who attributes all failures, all mistakes, all crimes to those around him, as if he himself (alone of all humans) is blameless? Where there is no capacity for shame, there is none for insight, much less transformation. Without the secret struggle against the self, there can be no drama, only pathos.
 
As for us, the beholders of this narrative, there can be no suspension of disbelief, no identification, and no recognition of our own fate being rescued by a confrontation with the truth. On the contrary, since this is not literature but life, there is only the increased awareness of the danger into which the world is plunged by having such a creature in the position of ultimate power.


 

View more stories

Submit a Story Search by keyword and country Guestbook